Wednesday, April 16, 2008

Controversy



There is a young lady whose blog I have read from her first entry. Now, I haven't been in blogland that long, but I went through her archives and read every entry she's posted. She's bright, funny, giving, thrifty, hard-working, and loves her family. I have enjoyed reading about her work in 3rd world countries as well as her self-set goals to participate in a triathlon--which she did. I don't agree with her politics, but I appreciate that she is not apathetic about the world around her. I enjoy her cooking adventures and her ability to stretch her budget with imagination.

But last week, she purchased an old flag from a yard sale (where it never should have been in the first place, but that's another story), cut it up, and made it into 2 tote bags. Now, I figured she was just unaware of proper flag etiquette, because I have read enough of her blog to believe she had only the best intentions. So I told her that while I applauded her creativity, I felt she was in violation of flag etiquette, and linked to a source that, besides giving instructions on how to dispose of a flag, clearly states it is not to be used to wrap or carry or hold anything.

One of her commenters took issue with my comment and poked fun at it. Other commenters tried to explain what the flag meant to them, particularly as vets and families of current military personnel, and one offered to buy the bags from her, so he could properly dispose of them. Admittedly, some comments were a little abrasive, but for the most part, folks were kindly in their criticisms.


When she didn't immediately address these commenters, I took it to mean she was truly considering what was said and I expected to find an apologetic posting. Actually, she was out of town and didn't see the comments til she returned. And when she did comment, it was to acknowledge that not everyone agreed on everything, and she thanked them for leaving comments. That would have been fine, if she had never written the next sentence--in which she flippantly pointed out that there were gazillions of other blogs and the disagreers could surely find someone more to their liking elsewhere.

Her readers all applauded her "recycling", stating they felt that burning or burying the flag was odd, outdated, not for today's world, and not worthy of being adhered to. Some plan on copying her efforts. Those of us who disagreed were considered to be "close-minded oafs", "morons" who need to find something more useful to channel our "moral outrage" to, and were generally chastised for stating our opinions. One commenter ridiculed Cookie's analogy of cutting up a grandmother's treasured wedding dress, which I thought was an excellent parallel.

Did these young people never pledge allegiance in school? Have they forgotten the words, or did those words mean nothing to them?


Why do they think that, no matter what the etiquette is, they are under no obligation to follow it just because they consider it to be outdated? If people disagree, that's fine--lobby to have the guidelines changed. Until they are, they should be respected and followed. Maybe it's a shame there are no penalties or fines attached to the violation of these guidelines.

At no time did this young lady aplogize for offending veterans of military service, or those who have loved ones in service now. And that is what I find most disturbing. Some of the last people on this earth I would want to offend or hurt, are our vets and our troops. They are out there voluntarily, far away from the ones they love and who love them, away from the comforts some of us take for granted, in conditions not too far removed from those this girl strives to rectify in other countries, risking their lives to protect the underdogs from their oppressors. Whether or not you agree with the war, or any past wars, our vets and troops deserve to be respected and remembered. Not disregarded. Not ignored. Not derided.


And this is why I removed this young woman's blog from my list of favorites, and will no longer be reading her entries. I am very disappointed in her response, and in the responses of most of her fans, and just cannot support her site with my hits anymore. I support their right to post their opinions, whether agreeing or disagreeing, but I choose not to fill my time or my mind with them.

"I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for for which it stands: one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all."


Edited 4/17 to add: I haven't mentioned the name of the blogger or her site, because I didn't want to stir up any trouble there. Let me say now that she has contacted one of her commentors and they have exchanged honest, respectful emails, and, though she feels the "thing" is not as important as what it represents, she understands now what the flag means to our military. The commentor, a vet himself, is satisfied that she did not mean any harm, and has published a follow-up response on her blog putting everything behind them. Let's us do the same.

10 comments:

Jacquie said...

I'm glad you took a stand.

Libby said...

Our flag is a very important symbol - one for which many sacrifices, including the ultimate sacrifice, have been made. Thank you for taking a stand.

MightyMom said...

wow, way to go Stephanie!!

That was very very well said!

I shall be linking to it!!!


And for the record.

Me Too!!!!!

Pen of Jen said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Cookie..... said...

Thank You Stephanie, both for your stand as well as your well written article. It was in fact, excellent!

When I left my comments over on her blog, I tried to be diplomatic, as did some others, and at that time I felt she was just "ignorant" (meaning unknowing of) of proper flag etiquette and meant no harm by it. When I failed to see any response from her, I was troubled, and then I read her later blog-post where she failed to acknowledge the feelings of the vets like myself, yourself or MightyMom, and "suggested we go elsewhere, I had a pretty good suspicion that she may have known about Flag etiquette and really didn't care...and thats her right I guess.

There are those who prefer to see only the ill's and problems of America, and trying to convince them otherwise is like ...excuse me...pissing in the wind. They are are the kids you grew up with who could always point fingers of blame, and snitched on other kids, but could offer no solutions or recommendations. An old addage I've always liked is "when I point one finger at you, I've got three pointing back at me." **sigh**...a lesson they will probably never learn.

I laud you for your convictions and courage, and I give you a well earned Thank You from my heart....

Cookie

Steph said...

Thank you for standing up for what you believe in and for holding on to a tradition that too many people have forgotton or blown off. I completely agree with you on this. Good for you!

Pinky said...

I'm proud of you for posting this, Stephanie. I'll be linking to your post, if that's alright. I've only read her blog a few times, but there are many young women just like her. They are more concerned with being 'green' than honoring the very men and women who protect their freedom and liberty.
Hopefully with a bit of age and experience, these folks will wise up and learn what's truly important....or maybe not.

Makes you wonder...is it REALLY about recycling after all??

Much love to you.

Cookie..... said...

Stephanie...sorry amiga, I just couldn't help myself, I just dropped a "forthright and honest" bomb on her "Can of Worms" post. Maybe y'all should check it out before she deletes it...which I'm sure she'll do because I confront her head on. No nastiness or bad language, but I hit her between the eyes....

LBP said...

Good for you! I find that lack of respect seems to be a big problem today.

I hope she will take a little more time and "think" about this.

Linda

Perry said...

I agree with you on your whole post. It is unbelievable that a sane American could do something like this. To me it just shows how much our American values have unraveled in the last few years. I don't think I have seen this blog and certainly will not read it if I ever do see it and realize what it is. Good for you!!